Farscape would win in my arena. I tried to watch BG but I loved the originals and with the sexchange of a character and a few other modifications, I just don't think I can enjoy it.

Farscape? I loved it and although they attempted to finalize it, they didn't.

AND, to put Ben Browder on Stargate and then add Claudia? C'mon. Still, after a few shows, Ben has proven his skills and has some of the nice acidity that was "Jack". But when Claudia is on I still get throwbacks to Farscape.